Apple Butter
Posted: November 17, 2026 Filed under: Desserts, Preserves | Tags: apple, preserves, simple, spices, Traditional Leave a comment

Spiced apple butter on buttered toast.
Wotchers!
OK, everybody stop what you’re doing and listen up. Readers not in the US grab a pen and paper because you need to get going on a shopping list. Any delay is going to stretch out the time between now – The Before Times – and the greatest dessert you can sling together in (almost) an instant. In order for that to happen, we need to crack on and makes some Apple Butter.

Today’s recipe is a wonderfully autumnal preserve that has a myriad of uses and a method of preparation that might be the easiest, simplest and most minimal that there is.
Apple butter is a rich, spiced apple preserve that is perfect for using up a glut, especially windfall apples. It originated in the Middle Ages in European monasteries with extensive orchards, presumably to avoid waste as well as being able to enjoy during the long dark winters. It is still popular in the United States and also The Netherlands, although the Dutch version (appelstroop) is made with the juice alone.
I’ve made many batches over the years, but didn’t have any left when I was testing various apple concoctions recently for the Apploffi Pie recipe. In the post, I suggested using Apple Butter instead of fresh apples, mainly for our friends in the US who might not be able to find the wonderful Bramley Apples I ended up using. Hadn’t tried it myself, but it seemed like a suitable substitution.
And it wasn’t meant to be a big deal – just a helpful suggestion, almost in passing – but since then I have not been able to get the idea of that combination out of my mind. Apple butter has so much going for it as a flavour partner with the caramel: sharpness of the apple, concentrated and reduced over many hours of cooking, the warm mix of spices, the texture of the preserve itself, which holds its shape without running with juice.
So I decided to make some, just so I could try it for myself. And I couldn’t try this Apploffi version without making some apple butter, so I dragged my trusty slow cooker out and set to work. As with several recipes that are used regularly, over time, shortcuts are devised and time-saving methods instigate so that I can get on with other things and leave recipes to their own devices. And so we have this recipe. Whilst not exactly time-saving – it takes hours to cook and reduce down – the actual amount of time that is hands-on involved is very small, and for the most part, it can be left to burble on by itself quite happily.
The key to this relaxed approach is, of course, the slow cooker. Initially using it with the lid to get the apples to break down, then afterwards with the lid off, to allow the moisture to evaporate and thus create the apple butter. You can cook this on the stove top/hob, but it requires vigilance and regular stirring to ensure the mixture doesn’t scorch.
As a recipe it is almost infinitely customisable, based on the combination of apples that you use. If you have an apple tree and a lot of windfalls, then this is perfect. Alternately, grab whatever is in the fresh fruit and/or reduced section of your favourite food shop.
You can also customise the liquid you use to get things going in the slow cooker. Obviously, there is a lot of juice in the apples themselves, but you need a little something to keep them from scorching until the juices start to run. Water is perfectly fine, but you can also use apple juice, carbonated apple-flavoured drinks (Appletiser, Apple Tango (use the sugar version if possible,q rather than the one with sweeteners)), cider or, as my latest batch, an apple-based spirit such as applejack, calvados or pommeau.
In addition, personalise the spices. Apple butter is traditionally spiced, and you can take this opportunity to add in your favourite combination to make it your own.
Finally, customise the sugars. This has less of an impact on the flavour than perhaps the other ingredients, but it is more of a permission slip to use whatever you have. You can use anything from fine caster/superfine sugar through varying shades of brown to Demerera and Dark Muscovado. Apple Butter is dark, as the sugars in the apples will also caramelise during the cooking process, so together with the spices you use, the colour of the sugar is practically immaterial.
What to do with Apple Butter?
Well, once you’ve got your apple butter, we can get on with, in my opinion, the finest dessert I have created in a long while, possibly ever – Apple Butter Apploffi!
Other uses can be:
- simply, on buttered toast. Or on toast with cheese for a savoury/sweet/crunchy combo.
- As a filling for cakes – Appalachian Apple Stack Cake is a classic.
Apple Butter
The following mix of apples is for those available in the UK. Use your local varieties, rather than trying to hunt down non-native apple types.
Important point – I chop the apples without peeling/coring, because it’s easier, and I can use my coarse sieve, with relatively large holes to remove the skins, seeds etc. once the apples have cooked. If you don’t have such a sueve/strainer, probably best to peel/core your apples before cooking.
Makes about 1 litre apple butter
2 Bramley apples (tart cooking apples)
6 Granny Smith apples (sharp, green)
6 Jazz apples (crisp, juicy)
6 dessert apples (sweet)
250ml liquid (water, apple juice, etc.)
400g/2 cups sugar, possibly more to taste.
2 tsp ground cinnamon
1 tsp ground nutmeg
½ tsp ground cloves
½ tsp ground allspice
lemon zest/juice to taste (optional)
- Chop each apple into 8 pieces. No need to peel or core, just use them as is. The pectin in the skin/cores will help the apple butter to set later.
- Put the chopped apples into your slow cooker and add the liquid.
- Put the lid on the slow cooker and cook on High for 3-4 hours until the apples have softened. Alternatively, cook on Low for 8 hours overnight.
- Remove the apples from the slow cooker and sieve to remove the seeds and skins. Use a coarse sieve with larger holes if possible. It’s not supposed to be a trial of strength here.
- Return the sieved puree to the slow cooker and add the sugar and spices. Stir well. If you’d like a smoother texture, use an immersion blender to blend it to your satisfaction. Taste and add more sugar if liked. I like sharp-tasting apple butter, so I use the juice of 1-2 lemons at this stage. You can use the zest as well, if you like, but that really ups the lemon-y flavour, and I like my apple butter to taste strongly of apples.
- Cook on Low or High (depending on the time you have available) until reduced down. It will be hours rather than minutes. Stir the mixture every hour to prevent a skin forming.
- Testing whether your apple butter is ready:
- The Heaped Spoon Test: Scoop a heaped spoonful of apple mixture with a spoon. If the mixture holds its high shape, proceed to the next test. If not, continue simmering.
- The Blob Test: Put the heaped spoonful of apple mixture onto a plate and leave it for 10 minutes. After this time has elapsed, check the edges of the blob to see if any liquid has separated from the apple pulp. If there’s even a small ring of liquid, you should continue to simmer the apple pulp a little longer.
- When your apple butter is ready, transfer to a suitable container and store in the fridge. Alternately, pour into hot, clean jars and seal as for jam/marmalade.