The Midnight Meringue

Midnight Meringue Pie


Cor! It’s been a while since I made a post – apologies for that, but it’s been a bit hectic since the final of The Great British Bake Off aired.

Now I know this is still a Bake Off recipe, but I wanted to make it a blog post just to fill in some background on how I put the recipe together. I did actually go through the reasoning behind the recipe on camera, but obviously it never made it into the edit. To me, at least, it therefore seemed like I’d just given a pie a bit of a poncy name for no real reason. So for those interested, here is the background and how I put this dessert together. Feel free to skip down to the recipe.

Still here? Awesome! Ok, so the recipe request for the Week 5 Showstopper Challenger was for: A Unique Meringue Pie. The guidelines were very specific in two respects:

  1. It had to be something much more than a regular Lemon Meringue Pie, and
  2. It had to be big. Huge, even. At least 30cm diameter across the base.

Obviously the size was going to test our skill in baking such a large pie, and the filling stipulation was going to test our creativity. So all this got me pondering how I could do something that was original, unique and achievable within the time limit of 3 hours.

Now when I think of a meringue pie, I naturally think of lemon meringue pie – and it just reminds me of a bright, sunny day: the circle of yellow like the sun, the mounds of fluffy white meringue clouds. So I thought it would be fun to make something that was a contrast – involving dark and light, very Ying/Yang. Then I thought about it a bit more and decided it wasn’t going to work – Ying Yang Meringue? Please.

So I crossed over to the Dark Side (Luke I am your father) and The Midnight Meringue was born!

Dark chocolate pastry, rich mocha filling and a dark meringue made with…..well, it went through several revisions, including (as some of you might remember) right down to the wire on the day itself! Treacle meringue, molasses meringue, coffee meringue – but on the day, brown sugar meringue won out.

I also decided to ‘assemble’ rather than bake the meringue, reasoning that less could go wrong that way – I could concentrate on each component individually and not have to worry about something over-cooking. The final dish consisted of a cooked Italian meringue made with brown sugar, a thick and rich custard filling flavoured with coffee and dark chocolate and a blind baked chocolate pastry case.

The meringue was piped in a huge swirl and finished off with a few blasts of the blowtorch to toast the edges.

The meringue was a little softer than the standard meringue topping because of the brown sugar, but I still think it was the right choice and really made the pie stand out.

This recipe is for a single large pie, but you could just as easily bake mini pastry shells and create individually-sized pies for a special occasion – and would probably be less stressful than worrying about one big pie. The fact that at least 2 of the components can be made in advance just makes it that much easier.

The Midnight Meringue

Chocolate Pastry
300g plain flour
40g cocoa powder
175g caster sugar
175g unsalted butter, cut into cubes
2 tbsp milk

  • Preheat the oven to 200C/180 Fan.
  • Grease a deep, loose-bottomed, 30cm tart tin.
  • In a food processor, mix flour, cocoa and sugar.
  • Add butter, cut in small cubes. Blitz.
  • Add 2 tablespoons of milk and blend again until mixture resembles coarse, damp sand.
  • Press the mixture into the base and sides of your pie tin. Alternatively, press mixture together and roll out using a rolling pin. It’s quite crumbly, so this is rather tricky and best done between sheets of cling film. Depends how critical your guests are going to be ๐Ÿ˜‰
  • Line with baking parchment, fill with rice/beans/baking bead and bake blind, 200ยฐC 180ยฐC Fan, for 10-15 minutes.
  • Remove beans, cover edge of rim with foil to prevent burning and return to the oven until fully baked (10-15 minutes).
  • Allow the pastry to cool in the tin for 10 minutes, then ease out of the tin and cool on a wire rack

The mocha filling
250g dark (70%) chocolate, chopped
6 large egg yolks
225g caster sugar
65g cornflour
1 litre milk
2 tbsp espresso coffee powder

  • Melt chocolate in microwave, stirring every 30 seconds to prevent burning.
  • In a bowl, whisk together yolks, sugar and cornflour.
  • Add the coffee powder to the milk and heat, stirring until the coffee has dissolved.
  • Whisk hot milk mixture into the egg/sugar mixture.
  • Return the custard to the pan and continue to heat, stirring, until it has thickened.
  • Stir in the melted chocolate until fully incorporated.
  • Check flavour. Depending on the strength of your chocolate, you may need to add more coffee powder.
  • Cover with cling film to stop a skin from forming and chill until required.

The brown sugar Italian meringue [1]
150g egg whites (5 large)
pinch of salt
few drops of lemon juice
45g granulated sugar
15g powdered egg white
150ml water
300g dark muscovado sugar

  • Put whites, salt and lemon juice in a mixer bowl.
  • Whip whites slowly until frothy, then fast until stiff peaks.
  • Gradually add granulated sugar and egg white powder (mixed together). Allow each spoonful to dissolve before adding the next.
  • Whip to stiff, glossy peaks.
  • Heat sugar and water to 115ยฐC
  • Remove from the heat and allow the bubbles to subside.
  • With the beaters running, pour the sugar syrup into the whipped whites in a thin stream, then continue whisking until bowl is cool to the touch and the meringue is stiff. This will take between 10 and 15 minutes.

To assemble

  • Place the chocolate pastry case on the serving dish.
  • Whisk chilled custard filling and pour into the pastry case.
  • Spoon (or pipe) over the brown sugar meringue. Make sure there are no gaps between the meringue and the pastry shell, and that the filling is completely covered.
  • Use a blowtorch to lightly toast the meringue. Serve.

[1] This quantity makes enough meringue to cover a single large meringue pie. If you want an awe-inducing mountain of meringue like the picture (although I feel obliged to point out that the picture is actually of a mini, 8cm pie), you might want to make double the quantity. If so, then I would suggest making two batches, because a single batch fills a standard mixing bowl.

21 Comments on “The Midnight Meringue”

  1. Mmmm I’m drooling already, fantabulous recipe!

  2. Beautiful!! I’m hoping to attempt my first ever meringue this week, but maybe just a simple one pavlova style and work up to something more magnificient like this!

  3. Thank you so much for this recipe!
    Ever since I saw you make this on the show I’ve wanted to be able to make it myself – you’ve just provided my Christmas-pud alternative!

    Keep on baking, you’ve been a great inspiration to me you wonderful woman! xx

  4. cookandbaker says:

    Hi, thanks for this recipe (and background into the name etc)! Could you please let us know whether the pastry’s more like a pliable short crust dough when pressed into the tin or like a smashed digestives?

    • MAB says:

      Thanks for the query – I’ll add a line to the recipe just to clarify too – but to answer your question now: when blitzed, the pastry is almost like wet sand. Now for the program, I pressed this together and rolled it out, because I wanted to impress the judges with the thinnes and evenness etc – but you could just as well skip this entirely and tip it directly into your pie tin and just press it into the sides by hand. Depends if your guests are going to be as critical as Mary and Paul, I guess ๐Ÿ˜‰ M-A

  5. Judi Delaney says:

    Thanks for this wonderful recipe Mary-Anne! Just got a couple of quick questions, is the espresso powder the instant variety, and why does the meringue have dried egg white in it – does it stabilize it or something? Your blog is a constant source of inspiration – I’m just lovin’ it!

    • MAB says:

      Wotchers Judi! Yes, the espresso IS the instant powder kind – NOT granules – purely because it gives a great concentrated coffee flavour and mixes in well in that form. The dried egg white is not compulsory, but I just find it helps stiffen the meringue (I also use it when making macaroons). Maybe a little more could compensate for the softness of the meringue when using brown sugar – why not experiment and let me know! ๐Ÿ˜€ M-A

  6. Becky says:

    Yum, this looks gorgeous – just need someone to make it for me, no time at the mo’! Whaddaya say?

  7. It looked fabulous on the show – I love the idea of a dark coffee filling – yummy ๐Ÿ˜€ Thanks for sharing the recipe – will give it a go but Italian meringue scares the bejesus out of me!

    • MAB says:

      Don’t be scared, Crafty! Although boiling syrup can hurt, as long as you’re careful not to splash it around, it should be fine. Just wait until the bubbles subside before you start to pour, and then pour down the side of the bowl and not onto the whisk itself. Happy Baking! M-A ๐Ÿ˜€

  8. rhona liddle says:

    i love and adore your work and passion and am mahooosively grateful for the time and energy you take to share your wonderment in baking with us to inspire us in our homes and impress guests etc. LOVE your posts! thank you.

  9. Bunny says:

    Wowsa! I’ve been waiting for this! It looks gorgeous.
    The components are very interesting.

    I do have a question, though; How can I convert the recipe to a standard 23cm tart pan? should I halve it?


    • MAB says:

      Wotchers Bunny! Half sounds about right – it might even be rather generous (depending on the depth of your tin) – but pastry can be frozen, filling can be eaten on its own, and meringue can just be piled up as high as you can sculpt it! ๐Ÿ˜‰ Happy baking! M-A

  10. paul says:

    Mary-Anne! Congratulations on making it to the final – you were robbed!

    You could really make this blog into something popular, you’ve got a really interesting edge. My advice would be to make it a bit more obvious that it’s you – a pic at the top or something – and get some decent links from all these people who are talking about the show on blogs etc.

    I’ve signed up for one!

  11. SugarDusting says:

    This looks amazing! I think I’ll have to build up my baking chops before attempting but it’s definitely now a goal!

    Thanks for sharing!

  12. Janice says:

    Lovely idea. Looks amazing!

  13. Jennifer says:

    So beautiful, this is a must try. Thanks for the background story, isn’t blogging wonderful, all that information to go with one recipe, and saves someone else from trying something that perhaps didn’t work. Love it.

  14. Hey Mary-Anne,
    when you made this on the show I thought it looked brilliant, and especially liked the idea of a brown sugar meringue. Its very creative and I love the name- can’t wait to have a go at making it myself as I love chocolate and coffee!

  15. Bella says:

    Mary-Anne I just think your the most wonderful person – your writing is hilarious and it has inspired me to try this Midnight Meringue, (and obviously all your other delicious looking recipes.) I hope all your achievements in and with the show and your blogging, is making your success go from strength to strength.

    Keep up the brilliant work, best of luck and wishes,


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.